The main task in doing so is to explain the sense in which tort law predicates liability on responsibility. And so, like the lobster ice cream sold in a seafaring tourist town, the existence of philosophy of tort law as a subject may seem to be proof that people will swallow just about anything that can be served up. May 21, 2010 tort law answers two of the most fundamental questions faced by any society. It supposes that the question of how people treat each other and the question of whose problem it is when things go wrong are at bottom the same question. Philosophical foundations of tort law owen, david g. Tort theory today is an exceptionally active and wideranging branch of legal philosophy.
American and commonwealth judges, however, have never fully accepted it. Tort law answers two of the most fundamental questions faced by any society. The contributions range broadly, from inquiries into how tort law. Philosophy of law 2080 tort law readings two conceptions of tort law ernest j. Tort law offers a complex set of rules to answer this question, but until now philosophers have offered little by way of analysis of these rules. Pdf on jan 21, 2015, avihay dorfman and others published new philosophical foundations of tort law. In this module, professor allen will explore the goals of tort law through a historic case. Tort law assesses negligence according to the conduct of a reasonable person of ordinary prudence who acts with due care for the safety of others this standard assigns three traits to the person. But the converse of this principle, namely that there can be no liability where there is no fault, offered an. Pdf philosophy of tort law frans xaverius academia.
Tort law articulates norms of conduct and resolves conflicts in the context of disputes between private parties. The law imposes a duty in tort not to libel people, not to trespass on their land, and so on. A civil wrong for which a remedy may be obtained, usually in the form of damages 2. Whatever the original foundations of tortious liability, by the 19th century it had come to rest firmly upon the notion of fault. A closing chapter illuminates how tort law enables philosophers to observe the abstract theories of their discipline put to a concrete test in the legal resolution of.
Tortlawexamnotes12 philosophy of law 2080 tort law. Tort law has developed over many centuries and has its origins in an agricultural society and. Definition of a tort blacks law dictionary defines a tort as 1. The blackwell guide to the philosophy of law and legal. Stanford encyclopedia of philosophy, theories of tort law week 9 tuesday 33 evidence law judith jarvis thomson, liability and individualized evidence. By contrast, the law of contract is based notionally on agreements, the terms of which are. Hart and tony honores causation in the law in 1959, and the relationship has never been better. How are concerns of distributive and corrective justice related. Pushed by problems in law and policy the nature of the criminal law jurisprudence and legal theory moral and political philosophy conclusion references philosophy of tort law the blackwell guide to the philosophy of law and legal theory. A companion to philosophy of law and legal theory wiley. Jun 07, 2004 and so, like the lobster ice cream sold in a seafaring tourist town, the existence of philosophy of tort law as a subject may seem to be proof that people will swallow just about anything that can be served up. Analyzing these four prevailing arguments against the amoral and, in regard to some, antimoral character of tort law, i shall seek to show that the normative structure of tort law can. In this course, we will investigate the philosophical foundations of tort law through. In these investigations, our focus will be less on what the law is, than why it is what it is and whether it.
By exposing students to the most important contemporary tort law theories, the fourth edition of this casebook encourages. We are asked to measure rules and doctrines and institutions and to guide the application of law by reference to the end of law and to think of them in terms of social utility. An introduction to the philosophy of law online library. He is the author of law and truth 1996 and the editor of philosophy of law and legal theory. Thus, philosophy of law addresses such diverse topics as theories of contract law, theories of criminal punishment, theories of tort liability, and the. East african cases on the law of tort download ebook pdf. Philosophical foundations of the law of torts oxford scholarship.
This volume of nineteen original chapters showcases the latest work by established and emerging tort. This site is like a library, use search box in the widget to get ebook that you want. The nature of law stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. Philosophy and the law of torts when accidents occur and people suffer injuries, who ought to bear the loss. Click download or read online button to get east african cases on the law of tort book now. This page contains listing of free law books online textbooks and tutorials they are downnloadable or for viewing online in the html pdf zip chm or rar file formats.
Jan 01, 2005 the blackwell guide to the philosophy of law and legal theory is a handy guide to the state of play in contemporary philosophy of law and legal theory comprises 23 essays critical essays on the central themes and issues of the philosophy of law today, written by an international assembly of distinguished philosophers and legal theorists. By exposing students to the most important contemporary tort law theories, the. Perhaps the most dynamic current in contemporary tort theory concerns the increasingly sophisticated inquires into the doctrinal elements of the law of torts, with the tort of negligence in particular garnering the most attention from theorists. What amounts to an adequate explanation of tort law. What is a tort a tort is a private wrong committed by one person against. This chapter is concerned with the common law, but it has a roman beginning. This volume brings together established and emerging scholars from around the world and from varying disciplines that bring their distinct perspective to the philosophical problems of tort law. Tort law offers a complex set of rules to answer this question, but up to now philosophers have offered little by way of analysis of these rules. The blackwell guide to the philosophy of law and legal theory is a handy guide to the state of play in contemporary philosophy of law and legal theory comprises 23 essays critical essays on the central themes and issues of the philosophy of law today, written by an international assembly of distinguished philosophers and legal theorists. The principle that a human being should make good the harm caused by his fault seemed eminently reasonable. This article explains the way tort law brings the fundamental questions together. View notes tortlawexamnotes12 from philosophy 2080 at western university. Chair in law, professor of philosophy, and director of the law and philosophy program, university of texas at austin.
Contemporary philosophy and tort law have long enjoyed a happy union. He is the author of nietzsche on morality 2002 and naturalizing jurisprudence forthcoming, and editor of objectivity in law and morals 2001. The other main branches are contract, property, and restitution sometimes known as unjust enrichment. This general question about the nature of law presupposes that law is a unique socialpolitical phenomenon, with more or less universal characteristics that can be discerned through philosophical analysis. This collection will be of interest to professionals and advanced students working in philosophy of law, social theory, political theory, and law, as well as anyone seeking a better understanding of tort law.
Problems on the frontiers of tort liability excerpt from causation in tort law, richard w. Philosophical foundations of the law of torts oxford. The purpose of tort law is to enforce those rights and duties 12. Tort law has developed over many centuries and has its origins in an agricultural society and largely rural economy of the middle ages in britain. Theories of the common law of torts stanford encyclopedia. Without going into the details of each, i will simply assert that what they all share is the plaintiffs entitlement to have defendant act differently. Is the plaintiffs injury hers to deal with, or is it one for which defendant is responsible and so liable in damages in each case, the question of remedy may be foremost in the minds of the parties. A modern perspective is an advanced yet accessible introduction to tort law for lawyers, law students, and others. Tort law assesses negligence according to the conduct of a reasonable person of ordinary prudence who acts with due care for the safety of others this standard assigns three traits to. Download product flyer is to download pdf in new tab. Contemporary philosophy and tort law have enjoyed a happy union at least since the publication of h.
Philosophical foundations of tort law oxford scholarship. The concept of a civil wrong cannot be investigated other than in the context of that classification. Of legal philosophy and general jurisprudence volume 11 legal philosophy in the twentieth century the common law world pdf kindle. Philosophical foundations of the law of torts hardcover. Twentiethcentury tort scholarship has been dominated by the holmesian conception of tort law as accident law, and accident law as a form of regulatory law. Minipresentations group 1 torts tort is conduct that harms other people or their property. John oberdiek ed, philosophical foundations of the law of torts, ox ford. Philosophical issues in tort law by john oberdiek ssrn. Theories of the common law of torts stanford encyclopedia of. Reflecting the way tort law is taught today, it explains the cases and legal doctrines commonly found in casebooks using modern ideas about public policy, economics, and philosophy. Even if you do not go in for legal theory, try this volume you will learn much about tort law and tort theory while getting to enjoy the virtuosity of some topnotch interdisciplinary, groundbreaking thinkers in the field. In contrast, philosophy of law is interested in the general question.
It is a private wrong against a person for which the injured person may recover damages, i. Note that the law of tort is the single major area of law which is still largely regulated by pure common law i. Philosophy and the law of torts edited by gerald j. She will address what makes tort law distinct and issues surrounding negligence and liability. Today, however, we hear of a revival of natural law. Philosophy of law is raising its head throughout the world.
Section 1 offers a brief overview of tort law and tort theory. Tort theory today is an exceptionally active and wide ranging field within legal philosophy. He has taught torts, intellectual property, sales, entertainment law, media law, sports law, employment law, and writing courses. In eight essays commissioned for this volume, leading legal theorists examine the philosophical. Moreover, in the last twentyfive years, some tort scholars have sought to revitalize the older common law conception of tort as a law of personal redress for.
Philosophy of law provides a rich overview of the diverse theoretical justifications for our legal rules, systems, and practices. Pdf a modern view of the law of torts download read. Hart and tony honores causation in the law in 1959. Philosophers of law are also concerned with a variety of philosophical problems that arise in particular legal subjects, such as constitutional law, contract law, criminal law, and tort law. Review pdf principles of tort law concise hornbook series.
Many duties in tort arise by virtue of the law alone and are not. The role of luck in the criminal law, kimberly kressler april 4. Utilizes the work of both classical and contemporary philosophers to illuminate the relationship between law and morality introduces students to the philosophical underpinnings of international law and its increasing importance as we face globalization features. Tort law is striking because it supposes that the question of how people treat each other and the question of whose problem it is when things go wrong are at bottom the same question. It furthers the universitys objective of excellence in research, scholarship, and education by publishing worldwide.
Section 2 discusses economic analysis, which is the historically dominant tort theory and the primary foil for philosophical perspectives on tort law. Two pioneers of the philosophical study of tort law george fletcher and jules coleman have offered accounts that expressly leave room for both strict liability. Thursday 226 negligence in tort law richard epstein, a theory of strict liability optional. The old and new philosophical foundations of tort law.
The union of contemporary philosophy and tort law has never been better. Despite its clear connection to a norm of reciprocity, the objective standard of care has remained a source of puzzlement and controversy, in a way that the laws indif ference to the plight of people with unusual sensitivities has not. There is almost no plodding in philosophy and the law of torts. Pushed by problems in law and policy the nature of the criminal law jurisprudence and legal theory moral and political philosophy conclusion references philosophy of tort law the blackwell guide to the philosophy of law and legal theory wiley online library. Probabilityraising and the law the punishment that leaves something to chance, david lewis causation, probability, and risk. Oxford university press is a department of the university of oxford. Philosophy and the law of torts cambridge studies in. Tort law governs how people may sue each other civilly as opposed to criminally in order to receive compensation for harms or injuries other people caused them.
Perhaps the most dynamic current in contemporary tort theory concerns the increasingly sophisticated inquires into the doctrinal elements of the law of torts, with the tort of negligence. In eight essays commissioned for this volume, leading legal theorists exam. Boshamer professor of philosophy and professor of law at the university of north carolina at chapel hill. This essay explains why, notwithstanding its uneasy seat between the esoteric and the banal, the philosophy of tort law is an. In eight essays commissioned for this volume, leading legal theorists examine the philosophical foundations of tort law. Johnson is an associate professor of law at the university of north dakota.
Overview of tort law, proximate cause, defense to a personal injury. The blackwell guide to the philosophy of law and legal theory. The law of tort is mainly concerned with providing compensation for personal injury and property damage caused by negligence. By starting from the roman analysis in which it had its origin, one can most easily set out the common law classification in which civil wrongs, or torts, form one important category. The essential difference between a common law system and a civil law system the predominant legal system in europe is that in the former judicial decisions are binding both on lower courts and on the court that has made the decision.
1524 1224 1006 1392 1614 335 1378 44 915 794 1008 736 217 657 198 1540 464 1472 239 962 1139 934 1099 712 568 332 25 1495 860